GOP Legislators Confirm Their Insanity on Education Policy
| By Ray Seaman - Jan 25th, 2010 at 11:02 am EST |
| Also listed in: Front Page Posters |
Comments |
Mail to a Friend
Categories: Education, Legislature, Republicans, Jeb Bush, Governor & Cabinet
Categories: Education, Legislature, Republicans, Jeb Bush, Governor & Cabinet
More than a decade ago, Jeb Bush fundamentally altered our state's education policy: a single, high stakes standardized test (FCAT) that would act as a universal standard of measurement for schools; taking on the teacher's union; and attempting to start a private school vouchers system.
At the same time, our GOP-dominated legislature kept education funding embarrassingly low compared to other states. They fought Florida voters' attempt to reduce class size by holding back funding needed to implement the class size amendment. Jeb Bush and the legislature's high stakes, low funding education policy naturally produced some crappy results.
Today, Florida ranks 43rd in SAT scores, 48th in ACT scores according to the conservative American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC.) The LeRoy Collins Institute has shown our dropout rate to be one of the worst. We're 50 out of 50 states and Washington DC in per capita funding in education.
And ignore the recent finding by Education Week that we're 8th best in the nation - we're not.
Florida's education system has been struggling mightily with Jeb Bush and the GOP's "reforms." So now what are they proposing? A lot more of the same: more FCAT, less funding, more demonization of teachers. The definition of insanity is trying to do the same thing and expecting a different result:
...just don't ask them or the big business allies backing these "reforms" to actually pay for any of this.
This leads us to the major problem facing Florida's public education system: we've been trying to educate the next generation of Floridians on the cheap, and (surprise!) it hasn't worked at all. You can't educate 2.5 million kids (the fourth largest student population int the country) with piecemeal funding. Not gonna work.
I'll be the first to admit funding isn't everything, but you have to have a strong base of funding with which to work with and build off of. As I said in a previous post:
And linking teacher pay to student performance? It's a great way to divide teachers against each other and continue to punish schools and staff that need more resources, not less.
Ending teacher tenure? That's taking an axe to a situation which needs a scalpel. We should be reforming "tenure" (which is kind of a misnomer - it's not the same tenure professors at universities receive), so teachers are protected from overzealous principals while "bad apples" are shown the door.
Education should be reformed, but doing more of the same isn't what's needed. Let's give our schools the funding and resources they need to do their job. Let's pay teachers better. Let's make teachers unions part of the accountability process rather than demonizing them. Let's provide students with small class sizes, a healthy learning environment, and a multitude of class options beyond just math and reading.
We can do better for Florida's children and our state's future.
At the same time, our GOP-dominated legislature kept education funding embarrassingly low compared to other states. They fought Florida voters' attempt to reduce class size by holding back funding needed to implement the class size amendment. Jeb Bush and the legislature's high stakes, low funding education policy naturally produced some crappy results.
Today, Florida ranks 43rd in SAT scores, 48th in ACT scores according to the conservative American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC.) The LeRoy Collins Institute has shown our dropout rate to be one of the worst. We're 50 out of 50 states and Washington DC in per capita funding in education.
And ignore the recent finding by Education Week that we're 8th best in the nation - we're not.
Florida's education system has been struggling mightily with Jeb Bush and the GOP's "reforms." So now what are they proposing? A lot more of the same: more FCAT, less funding, more demonization of teachers. The definition of insanity is trying to do the same thing and expecting a different result:
The GOP-controlled Legislature - heeding critics that the state needs to graduate students better prepared to compete for jobs - is poised to toughen graduation standards, link student performance to teacher pay and make it easier to fire teachers.
...just don't ask them or the big business allies backing these "reforms" to actually pay for any of this.
This leads us to the major problem facing Florida's public education system: we've been trying to educate the next generation of Floridians on the cheap, and (surprise!) it hasn't worked at all. You can't educate 2.5 million kids (the fourth largest student population int the country) with piecemeal funding. Not gonna work.
I'll be the first to admit funding isn't everything, but you have to have a strong base of funding with which to work with and build off of. As I said in a previous post:
With current funding, Florida can't even meet minimum obligations to its students, like having enough teachers in order to ensure necessary individual attention via small class sizes. Want to hire more teachers? Sorry, no funding. Want to build new schools? Sorry, no funding. Want to set up teacher incentives? Sorry, no funding. Want to try out new programs or test new ideas? Sorry, no funding.
And linking teacher pay to student performance? It's a great way to divide teachers against each other and continue to punish schools and staff that need more resources, not less.
Ending teacher tenure? That's taking an axe to a situation which needs a scalpel. We should be reforming "tenure" (which is kind of a misnomer - it's not the same tenure professors at universities receive), so teachers are protected from overzealous principals while "bad apples" are shown the door.
Education should be reformed, but doing more of the same isn't what's needed. Let's give our schools the funding and resources they need to do their job. Let's pay teachers better. Let's make teachers unions part of the accountability process rather than demonizing them. Let's provide students with small class sizes, a healthy learning environment, and a multitude of class options beyond just math and reading.
We can do better for Florida's children and our state's future.

Bravo. You've successfully just provided another empty talking point about the status of Florida's education system. We've accomplished smaller class sizes- have you spoken to your district leaders? Your board members? Your community? People- given the state of the state- are quite pleased with the reduced numbers of children per classroom at the district average. You can't have your cake and eat it too- even smaller class sizes or more per-student spending? You can't have it all and if you think you can, you obviously don't understand how state budgets operate.
Teacher's pay... ah yes, the classical sob story that our poor educators are over worked/under paid saviors of our communities. Well, I would certainly like if my job paid me for 9 months of work to work 7 to 3. If you reply with the "they do so much more!" argument, then why not advocate for increased wages for our police? Firefighters? They (unlike teachers) are on call 24/7, 365, and don't have any options similiar to your "tenure" in the education system. I'm pretty sure they provide services as necessary to our community as our teachers do (and teachers don't usually risk death on the job).
And just as a small side note... what are you afraid of with competing with private schools? Are you afraid that vouchers will allow people to choose better opportunities for success? Are you afraid that you can't compete with non-public institutions? If so, you fail to see what the private/public competition can accomplish; after all, our higher education system has proven quite successfully that public schools can be a great option to private instituions. However, I digress, and I expect you to fall back on the "sad state of higher education in Florida."
How ironic.